The Godfather vs Goodfellas
Two mafia masterpieces — which is the better crime film?
Advertisement
The Godfather vs Goodfellas
Two mafia masterpieces — which is the better crime film?
Click to vote — no account needed
Advertisement
More Polls 🔥
Friends vs Seinfeld
The two greatest sitcoms of the 90s. Only one can reign.
A hot dog is a sandwich
Meat between bread. Sounds like a sandwich to me.
El mate es superior al café
Amargo, caliente, y compartido. El mate le gana al café?
AI will take most jobs in 10 years
Is your job safe? Hot take: probably not.
About this poll
Two mafia masterpieces — which is the better crime film? Movie rankings cut across taste, era, and the specific moments films arrive in our lives. A ranking that puts the same film in S tier this year and B tier next year isn't fickle — it's responsive to where the watcher is standing. The matchup is The Godfather versus Goodfellas.
Why the question is worth voting on
Head-to-head questions like this stay alive because both sides have real defenders. The split rarely lands where the loudest voices on social media suggest it will — surface arguments are usually closer than they sound. Voting here adds a single anonymous data point to a question that, if you pay attention, you'll see come up again and again across the internet.
How voting works
This is a head-to-head matchup. Two options, one vote. Pick the one you'd defend in an argument with a friend. There's no half-credit, no "depends on the context" — the format works because it forces commitment.
Where the consensus stands
This poll is fresh — your vote is among the first. Be early. The first 100 voters disproportionately shape the consensus, because each new vote becomes a smaller fraction of the total. Lock in your tier list and check back later to see how the aggregate shifts as more people weigh in.
A note on methodology
Hot Ranking uses an anonymous browser fingerprint to ensure each browser votes once per poll. We don't store accounts or personal information; the aggregate you see is the unweighted result of every legitimate vote, with rate limiting in place to filter automated submissions. Results update in real time once you submit. You can read more about how voting works in our About page, and how we handle data in our Privacy Policy.
Share your result
After voting, you'll see how your tier list or pick compares to the consensus. The result page is shareable — most of our voters end up arguing with at least one friend after sharing theirs. If you want to see more polls in this category, browse movies or check out the Hot Ranking blog for essays on tier lists, ranking culture, and the great GOAT debates.