Rank Fullmetal Alchemist Characters

About this poll

Edward, Roy, Scar — rank the FMA cast. Anime rankings span four distinct eras of the medium — the classic theatrical period, the late-90s explosion, the long-form 2010s, and the modern streaming-era boom. Every era has its peaks, and your S tier reveals which era shaped your taste. The lineup includes Edward Elric, Roy Mustang, Alphonse Elric, Scar, and 10 more.

Why the question is worth voting on

Ordered rankings work when the order itself is the question. If you're sure #2 belongs above #3 — and you can defend that distinction — this format suits the question. After voting you'll see the crowd's order and where your taste diverges. The interesting positions are usually the ones where you and the consensus disagree.

How voting works

This is an ordered ranking. You'll arrange the options from best to worst, top to bottom. Unlike a tier list, position matters — #2 and #3 are not interchangeable. Use this format when you have strong opinions about exact order, not just rough quality groups.

Where the consensus stands

This poll is still settling. With 1 votes in, the aggregate is sensitive to new entries — your vote will visibly move the needle. Expect the percentages to shift over the next few days as the crowd grows.

A note on methodology

Hot Ranking uses an anonymous browser fingerprint to ensure each browser votes once per poll. We don't store accounts or personal information; the aggregate you see is the unweighted result of every legitimate vote, with rate limiting in place to filter automated submissions. Results update in real time once you submit. You can read more about how voting works in our About page, and how we handle data in our Privacy Policy.

The lineup

This poll has 14 options to rank. Each one was selected for relevance to the question and verified to have a working image. We don't pad rankings with filler items — every entry is here because it has a real case for inclusion.

• Edward Elric
• Roy Mustang
• Alphonse Elric
• Scar
• Riza Hawkeye
• Maes Hughes
• Greed
• King Bradley
• Winry Rockbell
• Lust
• Envy
• Father (Homunculus)
• …and 2 more

Share your result

After voting, you'll see how your tier list or pick compares to the consensus. The result page is shareable — most of our voters end up arguing with at least one friend after sharing theirs. If you want to see more polls in this category, browse anime or check out the Hot Ranking blog for essays on tier lists, ranking culture, and the great GOAT debates.